7 Comments
User's avatar
Michael Eriksson's avatar

Thank you Veronica. I also dislike it when people suggest that Zionism has nothing to do with Judaism. I think this is because they think Judaism is one thing instead of realising it takes many forms just as all religions do. There are bat-shit crazy forms of all religions and Judaism is no different.

Quick question if I may... why do modern Zionists get so upset when asked to define what a Jew is? I wonder what your take is on that. I have my own theory but I'd be interested to hear what you think.

Veronica Sherman's avatar

I'm going to be blunt. The reason Jews don't like it is because there isn't actually a definition of what being Jewish is. For some it's if you're following Judaism as a religion. For others it's about your ancestry and nothing to do with religion. And even within the those two groups there are endless divisions of what makes a “real” Jew.

Michael Eriksson's avatar

It’s almost as if being a Jew could be anything you want it to be? (I’m being naughty!)

Jennifer Grover's avatar

Thanks for your honesty and insights into Being Jewish and being a Zionist. I wish you were wrong so that I could hold more hope in commonsense and humanity prevailing in the Jewish community in Australia. Indeed we have so much work still to do in order to change the narrative.

Donna's avatar

Veronica, wondering if you’ve read Molly Crabapple’s Here Where We Live Is Our Country. I learnt a lot, especially about the barbarity of the relentless pogroms and the appalling conditions in the ghetto. But also, that there was, existing at the same time as Zionism, an honourable, if imperfect, (because all humans are) ideology which was the antithesis of Zionism - that the monstrosity of Zionism has mostly buried.

Raoul Christensen's avatar

I suggest (not jewish myself) that the way to identify if someone is a zionist, ask them if they recognise the right to exist of a man-made homeland for the "jews."

"Christian, Jewish or being Jewish (identify as Jews)," if they answer yes, then they are zionists first and foremost.

Leah's avatar

Thank you for always being so clear and concise.